A repository of (mainly) economic pieces of information (newspaper and academic articles, podcasts, etc) I have found interesting and useful and that I would like to share with colleagues, students or friends.
I have recently produced two working papers modeling the influence that richer people can have on the allocation of resources through the political system.
The first one (here) is co-authored with Pierre Pestieau (U Liège) and deals with "Lobbying, family concerns and the lack of political support for estate taxation".
Abstract
We provide an explanation for why estate taxation is surprisingly little used over the world, given the skewness of the estate distribution. Taxing estates implies meddling with intra-family decisions, which may be frown upon by many. At the same time, the concentration of estates means that a low proportion of the population stands to gain a lot by decreasing estate taxation. We provide an analytical model, together with numerical simulations, where agents bequeathing large estates make monetary contributions that are used to play up the salience of the encroachment aspects of estate taxation on family decisions in order to decrease its political support.
The second one (here) is written with John E. Roemer (Yale U) and proposes "An allegory of the political influence of the top 1%".
Abstract
We study how rich shareholders can use their economic power to deregulate firms that they own, thus skewing the income distribution towards themselves. Agents differ in productivity and choose how much labor to supply. High productivity agents also own shares in the productive sector and thus earn capital income. All vote over a linear tax rate on (labor and capital) income whose proceeds are redistributed lump sum. Capital owners also lobby in order to ease the price cap imposed on the private firm. We solve analytically for the Kantian equilibrium of this lobbying game together with the majority voting equilibrium over the tax rate, and we perform simulations. We obtain numerically that, as the capital income distribution becomes more concentrated among the top productivity individuals, their increased lobbying effort generates efficiency as well as equity costs, with lower labor supply and lower average utility levels in society.
Lane Kenworthy has just published two interesting documents on "Social Democratic America", with his ideas further summarized in a Foreign Affairs article.
In this one, he tackles the subject of income inequality, explains why it matters (including its impact on fairness, on equality of opportunity, on health,...) and should be reduced, but also why it should not be first priority of the US government. Among other things, he lists all the claims made against income inequality (including claims made by Joseph Stiglitz, that inequality is bad for growth and creates bubbles) and loks at the (lack of) empirical evidence. His approach is definitely not very sophisticated from an econometric viewpoint, but I like the way he sweeps the data/literature and summarizes it (keeping in mind he is no economist but a sociologist...)
In this second document (the first chapter of his recently published book), he takes a larger view and advocates the enlargement of social insurance programs in the US. His description of most public services as social insurance programs is very convincing and reminds me of Paul Krugman's quip that the US federal government is a gigantic insurance company with an army on the side.
I don't agree with all of the very extensive list of new social programs he recommends ("government as employer of last resort" ???), but I am very sympathetic to his argument that the larger economic risks the US population is facing (due to globalization, etc.) should call for a wider and better social safety net. On the political side, his argument is that the increased riskiness of economic life will translate into a demand by the population for more social protection, which will in turn generate the adoption in Congress of more social insurance programs. I am doubtful about the two steps in his arguments, mainly because they don't take (voters and parties) ideology into account, including the fact that very rich individuals have both the incentives and the means to try and influence voters against introducing new social programs (more on this in the next blog).
Anyway, I like his analysis, his long term perspective and a viewpoint stressing, in his words, that "Government Social Programs Have Economic costs, but Also Benefits"!
Every mainstream science which touches on political or religious ideology attracts more than its fair share of deniers: the anti-vaccine crowd v mainstream medicine, GMO fearmongers v geneticists, creationists v biologists, global warming deniers v climatologists. Economics is no different, but economics cranks differ in that they typically make false claims about the content of economics itself, as opposed, or as a prelude, to false claims about the way the world works. That target sometimes making it hard for non-economists to differentiate crankery from solid criticism.
Here, then, are some symptoms of bad critiques of economics:
Frames critique in terms of politics, most commonly the claim that economists are market fundamentalists.
Uses “neoclassical” as if it refers to a political philosophy, set of policy prescriptions, or actual economies. Bonus: spells it “neo-classical” or “Neo-classical.”
Refers to “the” neoclassical model or otherwise suggests all of economic thought is contained in Walras (1874).
Uses “neoclassical economics” and “mainstream economics”interchangeably. Bonus: uses “neoliberal economics” interchangeably with either.
It is always fun to look back at predictions and discover how wrong they were.
The SF writer Asimov tried his luck 50 years ago in the NYT. As often, there is over-estimation of progress made on hardware (robots, transportation, houses,...) and under-estimation for software (telecommunications, Internet, etc). But the two fields where Asimov gets it (nearly) totally wrong are demography and economics. Contrast his economic predictions with the recent book by Angus Deaton titled "The great escape".
By the most meaningful measures — how long we live, how healthy and happy we are, how much we know — life has never been better. Just as important, it is continuing to improve.
he New York World's Fair of 1964 is dedicated to "Peace Through Understanding." Its glimpses of the world of tomorrow rule out thermonuclear warfare. And why not? If a thermonuclear war takes place, the future will not be worth discussing. So let the missiles slumber eternally on their pads and let us observe what may come in the nonatomized world of the future.
What is to come, through the fair's eyes at least, is wonderful. The direction in which man is traveling is viewed with buoyant hope, nowhere more so than at the General Electric pavilion. There the audience whirls through four scenes, each populated by cheerful, lifelike dummies that move and talk with a facility that, inside of a minute and a half, convinces you they are alive.
The scenes, set in or about 1900, 1920, 1940 and 1960, show the advances of electrical appliances and the changes they are bringing to living. I enjoyed it hugely and only regretted that they had not carried the scenes into the future. What will life be like, say, in 2014 A.D., 50 years from now? What will the World's Fair of 2014 be like?
I don't know, but I can guess.
One thought that occurs to me is that men will continue to withdraw from nature in order to create an environment that will suit them better. By 2014, electroluminescent panels will be in common use. Ceilings and walls will glow softly, and in a variety of colors that will change at the touch of a push button.
Windows need be no more than an archaic touch, and even when present will be polarized to block out the harsh sunlight. The degree of opacity of the glass may even be made to alter automatically in accordance with the intensity of the light falling upon it.
There is an underground house at the fair which is a sign of the future. if its windows are not polarized, they can nevertheless alter the "scenery" by changes in lighting. Suburban houses underground, with easily controlled temperature, free from the vicissitudes of weather, with air cleaned and light controlled, should be fairly common. At the New York World's Fair of 2014, General Motors' "Futurama" may well display vistas of underground cities complete with light- forced vegetable gardens. The surface, G.M. will argue, will be given over to large-scale agriculture, grazing and parklands, with less space wasted on actual human occupancy.
Gadgetry will continue to relieve mankind of tedious jobs. Kitchen units will be devised that will prepare "automeals," heating water and converting it to coffee; toasting bread; frying, poaching or scrambling eggs, grilling bacon, and so on. Breakfasts will be "ordered" the night before to be ready by a specified hour the next morning. Complete lunches and dinners, with the food semiprepared, will be stored in the freezer until ready for processing. I suspect, though, that even in 2014 it will still be advisable to have a small corner in the kitchen unit where the more individual meals can be prepared by hand, especially when company is coming.
Robots will neither be common nor very good in 2014, but they will be in existence. The I.B.M. exhibit at the present fair has no robots but it is dedicated to computers, which are shown in all their amazing complexity, notably in the task of translating Russian into English. If machines are that smart today, what may not be in the works 50 years hence? It will be such computers, much miniaturized, that will serve as the "brains" of robots. In fact, the I.B.M. building at the 2014 World's Fair may have, as one of its prime exhibits, a robot housemaid*large, clumsy, slow- moving but capable of general picking-up, arranging, cleaning and manipulation of various appliances. It will undoubtedly amuse the fairgoers to scatter debris over the floor in order to see the robot lumberingly remove it and classify it into "throw away" and "set aside." (Robots for gardening work will also have made their appearance.)
General Electric at the 2014 World's Fair will be showing 3-D movies of its "Robot of the Future," neat and streamlined, its cleaning appliances built in and performing all tasks briskly. (There will be a three-hour wait in line to see the film, for some things never change.)
The appliances of 2014 will have no electric cords, of course, for they will be powered by long- lived batteries running on radioisotopes. The isotopes will not be expensive for they will be by- products of the fission-power plants which, by 2014, will be supplying well over half the power needs of humanity. But once the isotype batteries are used up they will be disposed of only through authorized agents of the manufacturer.
And experimental fusion-power plant or two will already exist in 2014. (Even today, a small but genuine fusion explosion is demonstrated at frequent intervals in the G.E. exhibit at the 1964 fair.) Large solar-power stations will also be in operation in a number of desert and semi-desert areas -- Arizona, the Negev, Kazakhstan. In the more crowded, but cloudy and smoggy areas, solar power will be less practical. An exhibit at the 2014 fair will show models of power stations in space, collecting sunlight by means of huge parabolic focusing devices and radiating the energy thus collected down to earth.
The world of 50 years hence will have shrunk further. At the 1964 fair, the G.M. exhibit depicts, among other things, "road-building factories" in the tropics and, closer to home, crowded highways along which long buses move on special central lanes. There is every likelihood that highways at least in the more advanced sections of the world*will have passed their peak in 2014; there will be increasing emphasis on transportation that makes the least possible contact with the surface. There will be aircraft, of course, but even ground travel will increasingly take to the air*a foot or two off the ground. Visitors to the 1964 fair can travel there in an "aquafoil," which lifts itself on four stilts and skims over the water with a minimum of friction. This is surely a stop-gap. By 2014 the four stilts will have been replaced by four jets of compressed air so that the vehicle will make no contact with either liquid or solid surfaces.
Jets of compressed air will also lift land vehicles off the highways, which, among other things, will minimize paving problems. Smooth earth or level lawns will do as well as pavements. Bridges will also be of less importance, since cars will be capable of crossing water on their jets, though local ordinances will discourage the practice.
Much effort will be put into the designing of vehicles with "Robot-brains"*vehicles that can be set for particular destinations and that will then proceed there without interference by the slow reflexes of a human driver. I suspect one of the major attractions of the 2014 fair will be rides on small roboticized cars which will maneuver in crowds at the two-foot level, neatly and automatically avoiding each other.
For short-range travel, moving sidewalks (with benches on either side, standing room in the center) will be making their appearance in downtown sections. They will be raised above the traffic. Traffic will continue (on several levels in some places) only because all parking will be off-street and because at least 80 per cent of truck deliveries will be to certain fixed centers at the city's rim. Compressed air tubes will carry goods and materials over local stretches, and the switching devices that will place specific shipments in specific destinations will be one of the city's marvels.
Communications will become sight-sound and you will see as well as hear the person you telephone. The screen can be used not only to see the people you call but also for studying documents and photographs and reading passages from books. Synchronous satellites, hovering in space will make it possible for you to direct-dial any spot on earth, including the weather stations in Antarctica (shown in chill splendor as part of the '64 General Motors exhibit).
For that matter, you will be able to reach someone at the moon colonies, concerning which General Motors puts on a display of impressive vehicles (in model form) with large soft tires*intended to negotiate the uneven terrain that may exist on our natural satellite.
Any number of simultaneous conversations between earth and moon can be handled by modulated laser beams, which are easy to manipulate in space. On earth, however, laser beams will have to be led through plastic pipes, to avoid material and atmospheric interference. Engineers will still be playing with that problem in 2014.
Conversations with the moon will be a trifle uncomfortable, but the way, in that 2.5 seconds must elapse between statement and answer (it takes light that long to make the round trip). Similar conversations with Mars will experience a 3.5-minute delay even when Mars is at its closest. However, by 2014, only unmanned ships will have landed on Mars, though a manned expedition will be in the works and in the 2014 Futurama will show a model of an elaborate Martian colony.
As for television, wall screens will have replaced the ordinary set; but transparent cubes will be making their appearance in which three-dimensional viewing will be possible. In fact, one popular exhibit at the 2014 World's Fair will be such a 3-D TV, built life-size, in which ballet performances will be seen. The cube will slowly revolve for viewing from all angles.
One can go on indefinitely in this happy extrapolation, but all is not rosy.
As I stood in line waiting to get into the General Electric exhibit at the 1964 fair, I found myself staring at Equitable Life's grim sign blinking out the population of the United States, with the number (over 191,000,000) increasing by 1 every 11 seconds. During the interval which I spent inside the G.E. pavilion, the American population had increased by nearly 300 and the world's population by 6,000.
In 2014, there is every likelihood that the world population will be 6,500,000,000 and the population of the United States will be 350,000,000. Boston-to-Washington, the most crowded area of its size on the earth, will have become a single city with a population of over 40,000,000.
Population pressure will force increasing penetration of desert and polar areas. Most surprising and, in some ways, heartening, 2014 will see a good beginning made in the colonization of the continental shelves. Underwater housing will have its attractions to those who like water sports, and will undoubtedly encourage the more efficient exploitation of ocean resources, both food and mineral. General Motors shows, in its 1964 exhibit, the model of an underwater hotel of what might be called mouth-watering luxury. The 2014 World's Fair will have exhibits showing cities in the deep sea with bathyscaphe liners carrying men and supplies across and into the abyss.
Ordinary agriculture will keep up with great difficulty and there will be "farms" turning to the more efficient micro-organisms. Processed yeast and algae products will be available in a variety of flavors. The 2014 fair will feature an Algae Bar at which "mock-turkey" and "pseudosteak" will be served. It won't be bad at all (if you can dig up those premium prices), but there will be considerable psychological resistance to such an innovation.
Although technology will still keep up with population through 2014, it will be only through a supreme effort and with but partial success. Not all the world's population will enjoy the gadgety world of the future to the full. A larger portion than today will be deprived and although they may be better off, materially, than today, they will be further behind when compared with the advanced portions of the world. They will have moved backward, relatively.
Nor can technology continue to match population growth if that remains unchecked. Consider Manhattan of 1964, which has a population density of 80,000 per square mile at night and of over 100,000 per square mile during the working day. If the whole earth, including the Sahara, the Himalayan Mountain peaks, Greenland, Antarctica and every square mile of the ocean bottom, to the deepest abyss, were as packed as Manhattan at noon, surely you would agree that no way to support such a population (let alone make it comfortable) was conceivable. In fact, support would fail long before the World-Manhattan was reached.
Well, the earth's population is now about 3,000,000,000 and is doubling every 40 years. If this rate of doubling goes unchecked, then a World-Manhattan is coming in just 500 years. All earth will be a single choked Manhattan by A.D. 2450 and society will collapse long before that!
There are only two general ways of preventing this: (1) raise the death rate; (2) lower the birth rate. Undoubtedly, the world of AD. 2014 will have agreed on the latter method. Indeed, the increasing use of mechanical devices to replace failing hearts and kidneys, and repair stiffening arteries and breaking nerves will have cut the death rate still further and have lifted the life expectancy in some parts of the world to age 85.
There will, therefore, be a worldwide propaganda drive in favor of birth control by rational and humane methods and, by 2014, it will undoubtedly have taken serious effect. The rate of increase of population will have slackened*but, I suspect, not sufficiently.
One of the more serious exhibits at the 2014 World's Fair, accordingly, will be a series of lectures, movies and documentary material at the World Population Control Center (adults only; special showings for teen-agers).
The situation will have been made the more serious by the advances of automation. The world of A.D. 2014 will have few routine jobs that cannot be done better by some machine than by any human being. Mankind will therefore have become largely a race of machine tenders. Schools will have to be oriented in this direction. Part of the General Electric exhibit today consists of a school of the future in which such present realities as closed-circuit TV and programmed tapes aid the teaching process. It is not only the techniques of teaching that will advance, however, but also the subject matter that will change. All the high-school students will be taught the fundamentals of computer technology will become proficient in binary arithmetic and will be trained to perfection in the use of the computer languages that will have developed out of those like the contemporary "Fortran" (from "formula translation").
Even so, mankind will suffer badly from the disease of boredom, a disease spreading more widely each year and growing in intensity. This will have serious mental, emotional and sociological consequences, and I dare say that psychiatry will be far and away the most important medical specialty in 2014. The lucky few who can be involved in creative work of any sort will be the true elite of mankind, for they alone will do more than serve a machine.
Indeed, the most somber speculation I can make about A.D. 2014 is that in a society of enforced leisure, the most glorious single word in the vocabulary will have become work!
Le pouvoir du lobby des taxis est décidément impressionnant! Il avaient déjà fait reculer le gouvernement sous Sarkozy (lire le chapitre consacré à la non-réforme des taxis dans le splendide livre de mes collègues Pierre Cahuc et André Zylberberg "Les réformes ratées du Président Sarkozy"). D'un point de vue normatif, c'est un des secteurs qui devraient être les plus faciles à réformer: une infime minorité de propriétaires de taxis qui grâce à leur rareté pousse les prix (surtout en province) vers des sommets, au détriment du reste de la population. D'un point de vue positif, la dilution des bénéfices de la réforme et la concentration de ses coûts explique sans doute le succès des propriétaires de taxi à protéger leur chasse gardée. Il n'empêche qu'il devrait être possible de compenser les perdants tout en libéralisant ce secteur au bénéfice de l'ensemble de la population.
Trois commentaires plus mineurs:
(i) le titre de l'article est trompeur: comme l'indique l'article dès le début, il s'agit de limiter la concurrence à laquelle font face les taxis, et non de l'encadrer!
(ii) quelle micro-régulation! Va-t-il falloir engager des fonctionnaires pour vérifier que le délai de 15 minutes est respecté...?
(iii) je me souviens d'un Manuel Valls, ouvert à la concurrence et prônant des idées intéressantes lors de la primaire présidentielle socialiste l'an dernier. Sans doute un homonyme du Manuel Valls qui exerce au Ministère de l'Intérieur depuis l'élection, et qui ne rate jamais une occasion d'adopter la politique la plus protectionniste possible...
Le gouvernement publiera, dans les prochains jours au Journal officiel, le décret instaurant pour les véhicules de tourisme avec chauffeur (VTC) un délai de quinze minutes entre la réservation de la course et la prise en charge du passager, selon une source gouvernementale. L'entrée en vigueur de cette disposition aura lieu, comme prévu, au 1er janvier 2014.
Visant à limiter la concurrence entre les taxis et les sociétés de VTC comme Uber, LeCab ou SnapCar, le texte a été signé par les deux ministres concernés, le ministre de l'intérieur, Manuel Valls et la ministre de l'artisanat, du commerce et du tourisme, Sylvia Pinel.
Politiquement, l'affaire est délicate. L'annonce de l'instauration de ce délai de 15 minutes, début octobre, avait donné lieu à un rétropédalage éclair de Matignon devant la pression des taxis. Ces derniers avaient obtenu – en 24 heures chrono–, la suppression des larges exceptions au délai contenues dans la première version du décret.
« DISTORSION DANS LA CONCURRENCE »
D'abord satisfaits, les VTC avaient donc rapidement déchanté, et crié à la victoire du corporatisme au détriment de l'innovation. Plusieurs sociétés de VTC ont expliqué qu'elles attaqueraient le décret « seconde version » dès sa sortie, devant le Conseil d'Etat ou à Bruxelles. Elles n'ont pas changé d'avis.
D'autant qu'elles peuvent s'appuyer sur l'avis de l'Autorité de la concurrence. Consultée par le gouvernement, celle-ci a indiqué, le 20 décembre, que le décret instituant les 15 minutes constitue «une distorsion dans la concurrence entre VTC et radio-taxis, qui n'est pas justifiée par les impératifs d'intérêt général affichés. » Le « gendarme » de la concurrence a suggéré au gouvernement de l'abandonner.
«L'avis de l'Autorité de la concurrence nous donne des arguments. Si le décret sort, nous prévoyons toujours d'attaquer le texte en justice, au Conseil d'Etat avec un référé et une procédure sur le fond », indique le dirigeant d'une société de VTC.
«Le décret est le résultat de longs mois de concertation entre les différentes parties. C'est un consensus, souligne-t-on au sein du gouvernement. Le cas échéant, nous laisserons la justice se prononcer. »
I wish some French newspaper/magazine would dare writing the same thing... (please correct me if some such piece exists...)
The Economist is always at its best when promoting free trade, including the free movement of people. It is so refreshing to read a piece that is not advocating some form or other of protectionism.
An open letter to the citizens of Bulgaria and Romania
BRITAIN’S newspapers are full of stories about your poverty, criminality and hunger for welfare. Its politicians rail against the European freedom-of-movement rules that will let you in and scramble to make it harder for you to claim benefits. Its population is more hostile than the Germans or the French: almost half of Britons believe their government should ban you from the country even if it is against the law to do so. You might just, as a result, have got the impression that you are not welcome.
But you are. On behalf of The Economist’s home country, we invite you to come and work here. Beginning on January 1st, you can go anywhere in the European Union. We hope lots of you choose Britain. Although our leaders seem to have forgotten, Britain pushed for your country to join the EU, knowing that you would one day turn up on our doorstep.
The going will be rough at first. But the history of many waves of immigration tells us that, before too long, you will be folded comfortably into British society.
More than we bargained for
It is not your fault that most of our countrymen don’t want you. Partly, the problem is the Poles. Ten years ago, when Britain was one of only three countries to open its doors to them, the government assured voters that just a few tens of thousands would come, and probably not for long. Instead more than half a million arrived. And, as well as being workers who cut cabbages and painted walls (displacing some British labourers by the simple expedient of turning up on time), they proved to be human beings who settled down and had children. We weren’t fully prepared for that.
But if our leaders were wrong a decade ago about the number of Poles and other east Europeans who would come to Britain, they are more wrong now about their effect on the country. Politicians claim they are a burden on public services already stretched thin by austerity. Nonsense: being young and able-bodied, they don’t use them much. And because they contribute more to the Treasury in taxes than they take out in benefits and services—about 35% more, according to a plausible estimate—they save our schools and hospitals from deeper cuts. They don’t depress wages much, and mostly among other immigrant workers. They make our economy bigger, lowering our debt-to-GDP ratio. If you are even remotely like them, you will be an economic boon.
Sadly, opinion polls do not lie. Few people want you here. Those of you who end up begging or stealing—and there will inevitably be some—will be featured on the front pages of our newspapers. But in an odd way, this could help you. So loathsome is the idea of Bulgarian and Romanian immigration to Britons that the reality can only seem pleasant by comparison. People will be nicely surprised when the great majority of you come to work rather than scrounge off the state.
Britain’s labour market is Europe’s most flexible. Its economy is at last growing strongly. Its people are not prejudiced in practice: the polls that show huge opposition to your arrival also suggest that most Britons would consider employing you to work on their houses. The country is used to immigrants. Particularly in London, you will discover all kinds of exotic folk, many of whom were similarly despised when they first arrived. If you are really worried about prejudice, just pretend to be Italian. Nobody will know.
In these articles, Krugman looks at the recent downgrade of French public debt by S&P(*), and makes the following point:
"It can’t be overemphasized that the rating agencies have no, repeat no, special information about national solvency — especially for big countries like France. Does S&P have inside knowledge of the state of French finances? No. Does it have a better macroeconomic model than, say, the IMF — or for that matter just about any one of the men and women sitting in this IMF conference room with me? You have to be kidding." Point well taken, and so obvious that rarely mentioned in the media... Krugman then provides several figures showing that France has not performed too badly (in terms of GDP/capita or public debt) compared to its neighbors recently. "By just about any measure I can find, however, France looks not too bad by European standards. GDP has recovered roughly to pre-crisis levels; the budget deficit is fairly small and the medium-term debt outlook not at all scary; the long-term budget outlook is actually pretty good compared with its neighbors, thanks to a higher birth rate."
He then argues that France is being "punished" for having (more or less) balanced its long term budget by increasing taxes rather than by decreasing expenditures: "Again, the point is not that France is problem-free; the question is why this only moderately troubled nation attracts rating downgrades and so much apocalyptic rhetoric.
And the answer just has to be politics. France’s sin isn’t excessive debt, especially poor growth, lousy productivity (it has more or less matched Germany since 2000), poor job growth (ditto), or anything like that. Its sin is that of balancing its budget by raising taxes instead of slashing benefits. There’s no evidence that this is a disastrous policy — and in fact bond markets don’t seem concerned — but who needs evidence?"
It seems that President Hollande still has at least one supporter ... overseas.
I actually believe that Krugman would be less sanguine if he were to delve into the microeconomics of the French policies of the last years. It may be OK to increase taxes rather than decreasing expenditures (I'll leave that to macroeconomists), but this falls far short of proving that the way taxes are increased currently is consistent with any n-best optimum... (n=2;3,...)
(*) A nice pun by Le Canard enchaîné: We use to be standard, now we are poor...